The KPI Jungle on Amazon
Amazon is overflowing with metrics. Clicks, impressions, CTRs, PPC ACoS, TACoS, ROAS, conversion rates, and more. But the real challenge isn't knowing all these numbers. It's understanding which ones actually move the needle.
Too many agencies and brands get lost in granular metrics, optimize the wrong levers, and lose sight of the bigger picture: overall account performance. As a leading Amazon agency, we see this pattern across the marketplace every day.
Why Most Agencies Misread KPIs
One of the biggest problems in the Amazon space is that agencies only analyze a fraction of the relevant metrics correctly. Even when they get that fraction right, they tend to get lost in the details.
The result: decisions are based on KPIs that have almost no bearing on long-term success. Instead of evaluating overall performance, campaigns get optimized in isolation without anyone keeping the big picture in view.
The outcome? Accounts that appear to perform well on paper, while revenue, profit, and market share stagnate or decline.
The Three KPIs That Drive Sustainable Growth
When it comes to evaluating Amazon performance, three core metrics matter most:
1. Revenue
The most important indicator of whether a strategy is working. Every optimization must ultimately be measured by the revenue it generates.
2. Total ACoS (TACoS)
Unlike standard PPC ACoS, TACoS measures ad spend relative to total revenue. This reveals how efficiently advertising truly works and whether it's driving sustainable growth.
3. Profit
Revenue alone isn't enough. A campaign is only successful if it leaves clear profit at the end. This is one of the biggest differences between surface-level optimization and real strategic management.
Beyond these, additional KPIs feed into the overall assessment: your product's BSR (Best Seller Rank), competitor BSR values, and both organic and sponsored rankings. These supplementary data points help pinpoint market share and visibility with precision.
ACoS vs. TACoS: The Critical Perspective Shift
Many agencies focus exclusively on PPC ACoS, and that's often the wrong call. PPC ACoS only measures the efficiency of individual campaigns. For strategic decisions, what matters is how the entire advertising structure impacts overall performance.
As long as revenue, profit, and TACoS are trending in the right direction, pure PPC ACoS becomes far less important. A low TACoS paired with stable or growing revenue signals that advertising is working profitably while simultaneously improving organic rankings.
Common KPI Traps
A frequent mistake is placing too much weight on irrelevant metrics:
- Click-through rates
- Impression shares
- Video view rates
- Individual keyword click counts
These metrics can be useful in specific situations, for instance when diagnosing a poorly performing campaign. But in day-to-day operations, they're secondary. Focusing on these numbers risks losing sight of the overall picture.
Example: A rising CTR sounds positive but can coincide with declining revenue and profit. Optimizations must always be evaluated in the context of total account performance.
Brand Traffic vs. Generic Traffic: An Underrated Lever
Another area where many agencies miss the mark is brand traffic. Brands often spend significant budget driving users to their own branded keywords. The problem: that budget is then missing from generic keyword positioning, where the real competition happens.
Strategically, it makes sense to keep brand campaign spend as lean as possible and focus budget on generic keywords to capture new market share. Brand awareness only drives growth when it's complemented by generic visibility.
Communicating KPI Results the Right Way
The skill isn't just in the analysis. It's in communicating results clearly. Clients rarely care about how a CTR, impression share, or individual video view rate developed.
What they actually want to understand:
- How is revenue trending?
- How is profit changing?
- Where does TACoS stand, and what does it say about efficiency?
- How are organic rankings and BSR values improving?
Clear, data-driven communication ensures brands can make informed decisions without getting lost in the KPI jungle.
Conclusion: Focus Beats Noise
On Amazon, seeing the big picture is everything. Long-term success requires evaluating KPIs strategically and putting the truly relevant metrics at the center of every decision.
The best agencies distinguish themselves from average ones by managing fewer, but more decisive, KPIs with consistency, and deriving action strategies that lead to sustainable growth.
Questions about your Amazon strategy?
We manage brands with over €300 million+ in sales on Amazon. Let's talk.
